User Tools

Site Tools


wiki:troubleshooting_whistle-malfunctions

This is an old revision of the document!


General

There are a lot of reasons why a 3D-printed whistle might not work in some way, but generally they can be reduced to a few main tuning issues to check

  • Flow percentage issue (generally too little flow)
  • Pressure advance issue
  • bridging layers are not solid, allowing air to escape the chamber(s)

How a whistle works

I find it helpful to understand how a whistle works in order to troubleshoot what a possible issue is.

In the screenshot above, you have 3 main things happening
  1. Air enters via the airway
    1. The air accelerates, usually by gradually making the airway smaller
  2. Air hits the “blade”, creating a fluttering effect
  3. That fluttering, along with the air building up pressure in the chamber, makes the air inside the chamber vibrate, which creates sound

So a whistle will most likely fail at

  • The airway - too restrictive or an obstructed path not allowing air to accelerate
  • The blade - no fluttering
  • The chamber - air escaping and not building pressure

Practical things to check

From the above, we should check

  • If the airway has stringing or similar in it
    • You always want to “paint on” seams away from any of the above components
  • If the blade is not sharp
    • Points to a Pressure Advance or flow issue
  • If there are holes in the chamber walls or walls of the whistle, allowing air to escape
    • Could be flow, seam, or retraction issue
wiki/troubleshooting_whistle-malfunctions.1769400807.txt.gz · Last modified: by bb3d

Except where otherwise noted, content on this wiki is licensed under the following license: Public Domain
Public Domain Donate Powered by PHP Valid HTML5 Valid CSS Driven by DokuWiki